Tool Design Evaluating Artistic criticism Skills According To The Structural  Critical Approach For Fourth-grade Students In The Art Education Department

Authors

  • Alia Hadi Zidane Postgraduate student/College of Fine Arts/University of Baghdad
  • Haila Abd Al-Shaheed University of Baghdad\College of Fine Arts

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.35560/jcofarts1416

Keywords:

Art Criticism Skills – Structural Criticism

Abstract

Nikolai's concept was linked to the historical development of the human sciences, which led to modern philosophies being characterized by a critical nature that relies on analysis and analysis of the mechanisms of artistic and intellectual production. He is one of the artistic vehicles that tends towards the analytical and which began with description, decided to be linked to a complex skillful and philosophical vision. It was not devoid of variation in directional opinion, so it is necessary to possess knowledge with certainty in order to build or design a tool to reach objectivity according to a certain stage, and according to the premise of scientific logic that indicates that phenomena are hypothetical and do not prove stability permanently, but rather they are true stability. This requires relying on a critical approach to analysis, based on scientific foundations that make technical analysis a scientific analysis based on controls and starting points specific to the critical approach.

All of the research tagged (designed to evaluate the skills of successful educational artistic criticism for fourth grade students in the Department of Art Education) is four separate chapters. The first chapter is the research problem that concluded with the question: - What is the importance of designing a tool to evaluate the skills of successful, successful artistic criticism for fourth grade students? The aim of the research is to design a tool for evaluating artistic criticism skills that is ideally successful for fourth-grade students in the Art Education Department.

The second chapter included three sections, where the first section is titled artistic criticism, the second researches successful applications, while the third section deals with the skills of artistic criticism.

While the third chapter may not organize the research procedures, as the comprehensive research community closest to the topic of the current research and its procedures was gathered, and the researcher adopted the descriptive layers for my analysis, including those that are compatible with the research objective.

Finally, the fourth chapter, which summarizes the general visual description of the students’ analytical forms, is a very good concept in most of the analyses, and this may be due to a preferential direction of enhancing the description, which depends on the student’s artistic design vision without taking into account the instructions or general principles of the critical approach. The end of the research is a research mark that sheds light on the analysis and criticism of art, especially the critical approaches, because they include various modern analytical starting points, which are widespread and contribute to the analysis of many works in the field of art. It suggests conducting a study of analyzing the approaches with certainty and connecting them to the works of art education students

References

Haddad, Ziad Salem, Art Criticism, Research in Art Criticism, Dar Al-Manahil, Beirut, 1993 AD.

Hamouda, Abdul Aziz: Convex Mirrors from Structuralism to Deconstruction, National Council for Culture, Arts and Literature, World of Knowledge Series, Kuwait, 1998 AD.

Al-Khalisi, Walid Ali Habib, 2013, Developing artistic criticism among students of the Department of Art Education according to constructivist theory, an educational program, doctoral thesis, University of Baghdad, College of Fine Arts, Baghdad.

Al-Rawi, Nizar: Design is the structure of the system of relationships, Iraqi Plastic Artists Association, Baghdad, B.T.

Reid, Herbert, Art and Society, published by: Firas Mahdi Zahir, Dar Al-Qalam, Beirut, ed.

Al-Suwaitari, Muhammad: Structural criticism and the narrative text, analytical models of Arabic criticism, the structural approach to structure and personality, 2nd edition, East Africa, D.B., 1994 AD.

Shaheen, Najwa Abdel Rahim (2006): Basics and Applications in Curriculum Governance, Cairo Publishing and Distribution House, Egypt.

Schulz, Robert: Structuralism in Literature, Trans.: Jana Abboud, 7th edition, Arab Writers Union Publications, Damascus, 1977.

Shirazi, Shirin Ehsan: Principles of Architecture, Arab Awakening Library, Baghdad, 1980.

Al-Duwaihi, Muhammad Hussein Abdullah, The theory of art education based on art as a subject of study and the possibilities of its application in the schools of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, Journal of King Saud University, Educational Sciences and Islamic Studies, Volume 16, Issue 1, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, 2003 AD.

Al-Azzawi, Alia Mohsen Abdul Hussein Muhammad, a model for analyzing plastic artistic work (drawing) in light of modern criticism methods, doctoral thesis, College of Fine Arts, University of Baghdad, 2006 AD.

Al-Ghamdi, Ahmed bin Abdul Rahman Al Ahmed, Image Culture and its Social and Educational Impact, research submitted to the 18th International University of Philadelphia, Amman, Jordan, 2007 AD.

Opening the Door, Abdel Halim: Design in Fine Art, Mahtajer Press, Egypt, 1970.

Kezorel, Edith: The Era of Structuralism from Lévi-Strauss to Foucault, Trans.: Jaber Asfour, Afaq Al-Arabiyah Press and Publishing House, Baghdad, 1985 AD.

Muhammad, Hussein Jabbar, The effectiveness of mind maps in developing creative thinking among students of the Department of Art Education, Master’s thesis (unpublished), University of Baghdad, Iraq, 2015 AD.

Morsli, Dalila and others: An introduction to the structural analysis of texts, Dar Al-Thaqafa for Printing, Publishing and Distribution, Lebanon, Beirut, 1985 AD.

Munz, Peter: When the Golden Branch Breaks, Structuralism or Topology, translated by Jabbar Saadoun Al-Saadoun, Dar Al-Shu’an for General Culture, Baghdad, 1987 AD.

Downloads

Published

2025-12-01

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Tool Design Evaluating Artistic criticism Skills According To The Structural  Critical Approach For Fourth-grade Students In The Art Education Department. (2025). Al-Academy , 119, 257-268. https://doi.org/10.35560/jcofarts1416

Publication Dates

Similar Articles

11-20 of 626

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.