A critical reading of the artworks of Saudi artists through the theory of Erwin Panofsky
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.35560/jcofarts108/299-314Keywords:
Art criticism, contemporary art, art analysis, art education, Saudi artAbstract
This study deals with the subject of art criticism by using Erwin Panofsky's theory to analyze a few Saudi artists' works. The study aims to identify Panofsky's theory and provide criticism of some Saudi artworks using it. The importance of the study is that it enriches the field of art criticism in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and helps critics and artists in using Panofsky’s theory to analyze artworks.
The study sample consists of six artworks produced in 2021 by six contemporary Saudi artists. In the theoretical section, the study dealt with several topics; first, is art criticism, the second part presents Panofsky’s theory with its three stages, the final part deals with the beginning of Saudi art until present time and its sources of inspiration.
The study at first, used a descriptive approach to describe the artworks and forming the theoretical framework. Then the analytical approach for applying the theory in the analysis of artistic works.
The study concluded that Art Criticism is a very essential elements in influencing Fine Arts. Also, it helps artists to improve their methods. As for recommendations, it illustrates the need for updating art education curriculum, in addition to adding lessons in Art Criticism
References
Abu Zaid, E. (2010). The concept of criticism in art education to develop critical thinking skills. Mansoura University Journal, 3(5), 1702-1720.
Al-Basiouni, M. (1986). Education of aesthetic taste. Knowledge House.
Al-Fahdawi, S and Baiwi, I. (April 2011). Developing artistic criticism for postgraduate students in the Department of Art Education in the light of the structural critical approach. [submitted research]. The Eleventh Scientific Conference of the Faculty of Fine Arts, Faculty of Fine Arts, 116-140.
Al-Hazzaa, H. (2021). The reality of art criticism and its role in contemporary visual arts in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Journal of Science and Humanities, 6(15), 127-151.
Ali, A. (1995). Appreciation and art criticism. Dar Al-Mufradat for publication and distribution.
Al-Rasis, M. (2009). Fine art in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Arab League Educational, Cultural and Scientific Organization.
Al-Rasis, R. (2010). Surrealism in the Saudi plastic art movement between methodology and the social dimension.
Al-Sinan, M. (2001). The impact of cultural heritage on the artistic vision in contemporary Saudi plastic photography and the role of women in this field [unpublished master's thesis]. College of Education for Home Economics and Art Education, Riyadh.
Al-Sinan, M and Al-Issa, F. (2018). The symbol in the visual arts, Saudi contemporary art. Jordan Journal of Arts, 11(1), 51-69.
Al-wadi, A and Salman, S. (2014). Art criticism is a study of concepts and applications. Dar Al Radwan for publication and distribution.
Bahnasi, A. (1985). Pioneers of modern art in the Arab countries. Dar Al-Raed Al-Arabi.
Beljelaly, L. (2017). Art Painting Between Analysis and Criticism [Unpublished master’s Thesis]. Abi Bakr Belkaid University.
Cansu, Oz. (2017). Art History Theorist Erwin Panofsky. Aegean University. https://www.scribd.com/document/509441130/Cansu-Oz-sanat-Tari-hi-Kuramcisi-Erwin-Panofsky
Fadel, M. (1996). Art education, its entrances, history, and philosophy. King Saud University.
Hafiza, M. (2018). Contemporary plastic discourse in Algeria through the works of the plastic artist Maqdis Noureddine [unpublished doctoral thesis]. Abu Bakr Belkaid University.
Hammad, E and Mohamed, N and Abdel-Azim, H. (2015, July). Experimental thought in the modernization formulas of Saudi plastic art schools as an innovative approach to teaching arts curricula at Taif University. Education World Journal. 51, 117-152. Publication number. 10.12816/0031788.
Incirkus, B. (2018). Comparison of Mehmed Fuad Köprülü's and Erwin Panofsky's Artwork Analysis Methods. Istanbul Gelisim University, 7(45), 497-500. DOI: 10.7816.
Mazonowicz, D. (2011) Erwin Panofsky: The Icon as Logos. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/01973762.1980.9659030.
Panofsky, E. (1939). Studies in iconology. Westview press, a member of the Perseus books group.
Qazzaz, T. (2001). The Nature of Contemporary Art Criticism in the Saudi Press [Unpublished master’s Thesis]. Umm Al Qura University.
Qazzaz, T. (2002). Contemporary Art Criticism A study in the criticism of plastic arts. Special posting.
Stollnitz, J. (2006). Art criticism, an aesthetic study. (Translated by Fouad Zakaria). Dar Al-Wafaa for the world of printing and publishing. (Original book published in 1981).
Weitz, m. (1964). Hamlet and the philosophy of literary criticism. university of Chicago.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Noura Adel Al-Hathloul , Salma Salem Abdel Aziz Al-Zaid
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
